Teaching Kids Theology Part 16
TLDR: One barrier to some teachers and parents encouraging questions is not knowing how to respond when a child asks a tough question, especially one we cannot answer. There are a few basic ways we can respond in these times.
As teachers or parents discipling children, one of the best things we can do is establish an environment that welcomes questions because questions are an on-ramp to learning. And learning is the path to coming to trust in Jesus and live like Jesus. That’s why using a catechism in discipleship is so helpful; it establishes that questions aren’t only welcome, they’re critical.
However, many teachers or parents are hesitant to give a green light for kids asking questions for a simple reason: What if the child asks a tough question that I can’t answer? That’s an understandable concern, but it isn’t an insurmountable concern. The key is to be prepared and know how you can respond. Here are five suggested ways to respond when a child asks you a challenging question:
“What do you think?”
No matter if you know the answer to a question or not, it’s almost always good to turn the question back around to the child and let them take a stab at answering it. This not only helps them develop their thinking, but it also gives you a little more insight into where they are, which in turn gives you more opportunities to have deeper a vdiscussion. But there’s a side benefit to doing this: It gives you a little more time to think so you can respond in the best way.
“Here’s the answer.”
There are times when a child asks a question, even a tough one, and you’re confident of the answer. There’s nothing wrong with just giving a straightforward answer in these times. This is especially true when the Bible is absolutely clear on a subject. This could be done right away, or it can be done after you invite the child to try to answer the question themself first.
“Here’s what I think.”
This response is so important, but so often neglected. We need to be very careful to help our kids understand that there are answers we know are right and then there are answers we think are right. This could be because we haven’t researched the answer fully, or it could be because people have different views on the answer. For example, if a child asks a question about eschatology, there are several different interpretations of that subject, and we can’t be sure which is correct. In those times, we want to abstain from saying, “here’s the one true answer,” and instead respond in a posture of “there are a few ways people answer that, and here’s what I think.” If possible, it’s helpful to share the opposing views too in a respectful way.
“I don’t know. Let’s find that out together.”
If a child stumps you with a question—which is highly likely; kids are great at asking questions that we adults are usually too afraid to ask—don’t panic! It’s okay that we don’t know everything, and it’s important to let the child know that. So begin with the clear statement that you simply don’t know the answer. Some teachers and parents are afraid that this will diminish trust in the child, but it’s the opposite. Being quick to admit you don’t know something strengthens the times when you give an answer. But it also teaches the child that they too can’t know everything and helps them begin to be okay with that. However, as often as you can, follow this up by inviting the child to partner with you to look for the answer. This provides you with the wonderful opportunity to dive into God’s Word as you also help the child learn how to study it more deeply to find answers.
“I don’t know. And really, no one knows that.”
At times, a child will ask a question that no one can answer. It might be a question speculating on why God did something or why He didn’t do something. Or, it might be a question that brushes up against some of the great mysteries of the faith, like the nature of the Trinity or how Jesus could be fully God and fully human at the same time. In these times, start again by being clear that you don’t know the answer to the question, but then broaden it to clarify that no one really knows. Feel free to discuss some of your thoughts or what can be known close to the question (e.g., we don’t fully understand the Trinity, but we know for sure that there is one God in three Persons—Father, Son, and Spirit), but stop short of trying to resolve a question that cannot be answered (this is why we shouldn’t use any picture of the Trinity such as an egg or a clover; they all end up teaching error). Just like it’s important that a child understands that you don’t have all the answers, it’s just as important that they learn that they won’t have all the answers either. What we want to help them do is be comfortable in these mysteries of the faith.
If you are looking for a resource to help you grow as a theologian and to help you teach your children theology, Faith Foundations is for you. These ninety-nine devotions use an ancient tool called a catechism to teach the core doctrines of the faith. Each devotion features a Bible reading, a devotion, several engaging questions, a Jesus connection, and a suggested family activity. Faith Foundations is now available for purchase.